Go Paperless with Payroll & HR: 10 Reasons to Ditch the Clutter
August 26th, 2025 | 6 min. read
Still using paper for HR and payroll?
You don’t need us to tell you it’s slow. Or messy. Or a risk you can’t always see until it costs you time, money, or credibility.
You’ve got forms you can’t find, approvals stuck on someone’s desk, and a process that barely keeps up with the pace of your business.
This article breaks down 10 reasons to finally move on and what you gain when you do. Less friction. More control. Fewer fires to put out.
Let’s start with the most obvious pain point.
1. You Can’t Find Anything When You Need It
How many hours have you lost looking for one file? How many times have you asked, “Did someone move that folder?”
These delays don’t just waste time. They chip away at credibility. When leadership needs something for compliance or a last-minute report and you can’t find it fast, it reflects on your systems and on you.
Search...click....done.
Digital document management eliminates this guesswork. Search by employee name, file type, or date, and the right file appears instantly. There’s no second-guessing where something was stored or whether the latest version is in the right folder. Everything is organized, accessible, and trackable.
This isn’t “tech for tech’s sake.” It’s the difference between chaos and control.
2. Filing Cabinets Take Up More Than Just Space
Paper records don’t just require storage... they reduce the efficiency of your physical environment.
You don’t need to become a minimalist overnight. But if you’re clinging to paper out of habit or fear, it’s time to ask: What’s it costing you?
The advantage of digital storage
When documents are stored digitally:
-
You recover square footage for more strategic use
-
Teams can collaborate in more functional spaces
-
There’s no limit to how much information you can store securely
Digital systems remove clutter and create room for people and more progress.
3. If Work Isn’t Tied to a Desk, Why Are Your HR Systems?
HR and payroll responsibilities aren’t limited to what happens in the office. Questions come up while you're working remotely. Employees submit requests after hours. Approvals need to move forward even when someone is traveling. If your documents are tied to a specific location or desktop, you're at risk of delay every time something happens outside of your building.
"I'll check when I get back" is not a real plan
Paper-based systems or on-premise storage create a dependency on physical presence. That means decisions are delayed, communication slows down, and your ability to respond quickly is reduced.
A cloud-based HR and payroll system gives you flexibility without compromising control. You can access documents securely from any device, share information with the right stakeholders, and keep business moving even when people are distributed or unavailable.
Remote access is no longer optional. It’s a baseline expectation for your team, your compliance needs, and your ability to stay responsive.
4. Sharing Paper Slows Everything Down
If your team still relies on scanning, printing, or “walking something over,” you’ve got a bottleneck built into your process.
Paper creates silos.
When your processes depend on paper, every step becomes slower than it needs to be. Documents need to be printed, handed off, reviewed manually, and filed again. If someone is out of the office or misses a step, the entire process stalls.
Even small tasks like getting a signature or submitting a form can stretch into days instead of minutes. And because there’s no automatic record of status or ownership, it’s easy for things to fall through the cracks.
Digital workflows change that.
Documents can be routed automatically, reviewed in real time, and stored in the right place without anyone chasing down approvals or wondering where things stand. You gain visibility into the process, and your team spends less time managing logistics.
Every handoff that happens on paper creates a new opportunity for error, delay, or miscommunication. A digital system removes that friction and makes collaboration seamless, even across locations.
5. Manual Systems Come with Hidden Costs
You might not notice it at first. A few boxes of paper here, a new toner cartridge there. But the costs of paper-based payroll and HR are bigger than you think.
Every sheet of paper has a price tag
-
Printing and copying
-
Check stock and envelopes
-
Postage
-
Filing cabinets and storage rooms
-
Time spent handling, filing, or reprinting documents
It’s death by a thousand cuts.
You’re paying more to work slower
The cost of sticking with paper-based payroll and HR processes isn’t just in the supplies. It’s in the time your team spends managing them, the errors that creep in, and the resources needed to maintain outdated systems.
Every printed document, every manually issued check, every misplaced file represents real cost. And while no single instance may seem significant, the cumulative impact is hard to ignore. Paper-based processes drain money slowly and quietly — but consistently.
Switching to digital helps you control those costs.
Automated payroll systems reduce processing time and prevent calculation errors. Electronic records eliminate the need for physical storage and allow for instant access to what you need. Fewer materials are used, fewer steps are repeated, and fewer problems slip through.
This isn’t just about being more modern. It’s about being more efficient and more responsible with your budget and your time.
You’re paying more to work slower
Direct deposit alone saves thousands in labor and materials. Digital onboarding removes the need to print, ship, or scan anything.
You’re not just paying for paper. You’re paying for inefficiency.
“We’ve always done it this way” isn’t a defense
If you’re spending money to keep a broken system alive, the question isn’t “Why go digital?”
It’s: Why keep wasting money and time?
6. Administrative Overload is Holding Your HR Team Back
In a paper-based system, even the most routine tasks take longer than they should. Hiring a new employee can mean printing dozens of forms, collecting wet signatures, and manually filing each piece of documentation. Offboarding or benefits enrollment requires the same level of hands-on effort.
You’re spending hours on tasks that should take minutes
All of that administrative work eats into your HR team’s time and energy. It forces skilled professionals to spend their days managing forms instead of focusing on people, strategy, and compliance. Admin overload doesn’t just waste time. It drains focus and creates burnout.
And worse...it increases errors. Paper is easy to misfile, misplace, or miss entirely.
Digital workflows remove the weight
When you automate these steps:
-
Forms are pre-filled
-
Signatures are handled electronically
-
Everything flows into one secure system
Your team spends less time pushing paper and more time solving real people problems (the work they’re actually good at).
7. Paper Makes You Look Behind the Curve
Employees expect digital access. Auditors expect quick responses. And leadership expects systems that can scale.
If your payroll or HR processes still rely heavily on paper, you’re not just slower, you look outdated. That perception matters, especially when you're trying to attract top talent or build internal trust. Paper doesn’t signal control. It signals friction.
If you’re not evolving your systems, you're falling behind the operational standard, and that gap will only grow. Digital tools are the baseline of what today’s teams require to work efficiently and securely.
“We’re small, so we don’t need it yet” is a myth
Whether you have 5 employees or 500, the risks are the same:
-
Missed deadlines
-
Compliance gaps
-
Wasted hours on basic admin
You don’t wait until you're bigger to get organized. You get organized so you can grow.
8. One Disaster Could Erase Everything
Fires, floods, leaks, or just a misplaced folder. It doesn’t take much for years of critical documentation to be damaged or lost. And when that happens, you don’t just lose paper — you lose protection.
Physical records are vulnerable by nature. Even the best filing system can’t protect you from accidents or environmental risks. And when something goes missing, it’s nearly impossible to prove what was there.
Digital systems are built to avoid that
They back up automatically, protect data with multiple layers of security, and ensure you can always retrieve what you need. Even in the worst-case scenario, your business keeps moving.
Relying on paper is a gamble. If your organization is serious about compliance, continuity, and resilience, then physical files are your weakest link.
9. Paper Can’t Be Secured the Way Data Can
When sensitive information is stored on paper, you’re limited in how you protect it. Locked drawers and restricted access rooms only go so far. You can’t monitor who looks at a document, when it was accessed, or whether a change was made without permission.
That lack of control puts your business at risk. From compliance audits to internal reviews, you need clear, documented access history.
Compliance isn’t optional
Laws like HIPAA, FMLA, and GDPR require you to:
-
Limit who can access what
-
Track who views or edits files
-
Store information securely for specific timeframes
Can your paper system do that?
Digital systems give you visibility
Access can be limited by role or function, activity is logged automatically, and sensitive data is encrypted at every level. If something is accessed or changed, you know who did it and when.
Protecting employee data isn’t just about avoiding a breach. It’s about maintaining trust, meeting regulatory standards, and ensuring that your systems can stand up to scrutiny.
10. It’s Not About Paper, but Progress.
Going digital is about creating space—operationally and strategically—for your team to do better work.
When your systems are built on paper, every improvement takes longer to implement. Every new hire, every policy update, every audit prep becomes a manual, repetitive task that slows everything else down.
Modern HR and payroll platforms are designed to remove that drag. They automate the routine. They surface insights quickly. They adapt as your team scales. And they don’t require someone to stand at the copier to make it all happen.
Moving Forward Without the Paper Trail
Paper isn’t just clutter. It slows you down, eats into your budget, and exposes your business to risks that are avoidable in today’s world. Digital payroll and HR systems remove that drag.
They give you faster access to information, better protection of sensitive data, and the flexibility to work the way modern teams already do.
You don’t have to overhaul everything at once. You can start small, build momentum, and see real benefits as you go. What matters is taking the first step toward leaving paper behind for good.
Going paperless is only the beginning. The real payoff comes when you use digital tools to simplify every stage of the employee lifecycle, starting with onboarding.
Check out our next recommended read: 7 Best Practices for Electronic Employee Onboarding in 2025.
This article walks you through the steps to simplify onboarding, automate better, and give your new hires a modern, efficient entry into your organization.
Note: This article was originally posted on 1/26/2019 and updated on 8/26/2025 to reflect the most current and accurate information.
Topics:
